The Wall Street Journal: Judge backs Apple in locked-iPhone drug case

A federal magistrate judge in New York sided Monday with Apple Inc. AAPL, -0.23%   and against the Justice Department, in a legal fight over whether the company can be forced to help investigators extract data from a locked phone — a ruling that could affect a similar, much-watched case over a terrorist’s phone in California.

The ruling, which could shape the broader battle over privacy, security and technology now being waged between Washington and Silicon Valley, comes a day before the head of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and Apple’s top lawyer are due to testify before Congress.

Also read: Why Apple is right in its fight with the FBI

Magistrate Judge James Orenstein issued a 50-page order rejecting the Justice Department’s claims that the 18th century All Writs Act gives prosecutors the authority to compel Apple to help investigators bypass the passcode-protection system on an Apple iPhone seized in a drug investigation.

The decision could have a ripple effect in Congress and California, where a judge is weighing a similar request in a dispute over an iPhone used by a terrorist in the San Bernardino attack.

In Monday’s ruling, the judge determined that the government’s view of the 1789 All Writs Act is so far-reaching “as to cast doubt on [its] constitutionality if adopted.’’ He said the critical issues of 21st century privacy and technology should be decided by today’s lawmakers, not by re-interpreting an old law.

An expanded version of this report appears on WSJ.com.

Filed in: Top News Tags: 

You might like:

Market Extra: Warren Buffett says don’t make this ‘terrible mistake’ when it comes to bonds Market Extra: Warren Buffett says don’t make this ‘terrible mistake’ when it comes to bonds
The Tell: Here’s why Warren Buffett says Berkshire could handle $400 billion ‘mega-catastrophe’ The Tell: Here’s why Warren Buffett says Berkshire could handle $400 billion ‘mega-catastrophe’
Market Extra: Warren Buffett explains why Berkshire can’t find companies to buy at a ‘sensible’ price Market Extra: Warren Buffett explains why Berkshire can’t find companies to buy at a ‘sensible’ price
‘Get Out’ is spending big to try and win the Best Picture Oscar ‘Get Out’ is spending big to try and win the Best Picture Oscar
The Wall Street Journal: Apple to store sensitive encryption keys in China The Wall Street Journal: Apple to store sensitive encryption keys in China
The Tell: 7 highlights from Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway investor letter The Tell: 7 highlights from Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway investor letter
The Margin: Watch as thirst costs this Duisburg goalkeeper the simplest of tap-ins The Margin: Watch as thirst costs this Duisburg goalkeeper the simplest of tap-ins
Market Extra: Buffett says new accounting rule will ‘severely distort’ future earnings figures Market Extra: Buffett says new accounting rule will ‘severely distort’ future earnings figures
© 8271 Stock Investors News. All rights reserved. XHTML / CSS Valid.