MarketWatch First Take: Trump is right to link national debt to assets

Now, we’ve got him.

President Donald Trump went on his second-favorite television show, “Hannity,” on Wednesday, and discussed one of his favorite topics, the stock market.

“The country, we took it over and owed over $20 trillion. As you know, the last eight years, they borrowed more than it did in the whole history of our country. So they borrowed more than $10 trillion, right? And yet, we picked up $5.2 trillion just in the stock market. Possibly picked up the whole thing in the first nine months, in terms of value. So you could say, in one sense, we’re really increasing values. And maybe in a sense we’re reducing debt. But we’re very honored by it.”

Read more on Trump’s comments.

WHAT A MAROON.

Except…

It’s not a totally crazy way to look at the issue.

Yes, the debt burden, to the extent that it actually matters, is spread across every taxpayer, while stocks are not widely held, and in fact, concentrated among the rich.

And stock market gains are on paper (though one can borrow against them without selling). Plus, they’re not entirely owned by Americans.

Still, to a degree, the ability to service the debt has improved because of the stock market’s rise. Some portion of that $5 trillion or so will make it into the hands of Americans, who will both increase economic activity as well as pay taxes on it to Uncle Sam.

Would I have linked it that way? No, a far more appropriate measurement would be to compare the national debt to the size of the national economy.

The question of whether the U.S. has too much, too little or just enough debt is for another day. But in thinking about debt in terms of what it actually buys,which is kind of what Trump did, is how debt should be considered. That the U.S. is $20 trillion in debt is only good or bad news to the extent that money is and was productively used.

If the U.S. grows its debt to build bridges to nowhere, then no, it’s not a wise use of money. If the U.S. funds expansions of education or infrastructure that allows for better and more economic activity, then it’s money not just well spent, but as Trump would say, in a sense reducing debt.

And in any case, Trump’s comments are a far better construct for evaluating the national debt than that of the zero-sum tea partiers.

Filed in: Top News Tags: 

You might like:

Tesla’s Semi to have a Founders Series version for $200,000 Tesla’s Semi to have a Founders Series version for $200,000
Here’s a timely reminder on Black Friday of America’s escalating credit-card debt Here’s a timely reminder on Black Friday of America’s escalating credit-card debt
Futures Movers: U.S. oil prices climb as traders focus on disruptions, OPEC meeting Futures Movers: U.S. oil prices climb as traders focus on disruptions, OPEC meeting
NewsWatch: The ‘Vanguard effect’ means your investments could soon cost nothing NewsWatch: The ‘Vanguard effect’ means your investments could soon cost nothing
Currencies: Dollar heads for third weekly loss, as euro gains more ground Currencies: Dollar heads for third weekly loss, as euro gains more ground
Bond Report: Treasury yields slightly higher after solid data affirms eurozone recovery Bond Report: Treasury yields slightly higher after solid data affirms eurozone recovery
Market Snapshot: U.S. stocks set to climb, with retailers in focus for Black Friday Market Snapshot: U.S. stocks set to climb, with retailers in focus for Black Friday
: As Black Friday sales kick off, social media swamps retailers with complaints : As Black Friday sales kick off, social media swamps retailers with complaints

Leave a Reply

Submit Comment
© 7318 Stock Investors News. All rights reserved. XHTML / CSS Valid.