Key Words: Robert Shiller: Passive investing is a ‘pseudoscience’ and it’s bad for markets

Robert Shiller, the Nobel Prize-winning Yale economics professor, is clearly no fan of passive investing, which he describes as a “chaotic system” that’s taking a toll on the business landscape across the United States.

‘The strength of this country was built on people who watched individual companies. They had opinions about them. All this talk of indexes, it’s a little bit diluting of our intellect. It becomes more of a game.’

Robert Shiller

The increasingly popular passive approach, of course, is basically when investors seek to mirror the performance of an index via a low-cost tracking fund, rather than looking to beat the market through active management.

Shiller, in an interview this week with CNBC, likened passive investing to coming up to a green light at an intersection and crossing the street without looking both ways.

“The problem is that if you are talking about passive indexing, that is something that is really free-riding on other people’s work,” he said. “So people say, ‘I’m not going to try to beat the market. The market is all-knowing.’ But how in the world can the market be all-knowing, if nobody is trying — well, not as many people — are trying to beat it?”

And it’s true. Not as many people are trying to beat the market these days. Investors are pouring record amounts of money into passive funds as the market keeps pushing into uncharted territory.

Read: Passive investing is changing the stock market in ways most investors don’t realize.

According to Morningstar, passive funds attracted inflows of $428.7 billion over 2016, while actively managed funds saw outflows of $285.2 billion, a trend that has occurred for nearly 10 years.

“It’s kind of pseudoscience to think these indexes are perfect, and all I need is some kind of computer model instead of thinking about business,” he told CNBC.

Watch the full interview:

Filed in: Top News Tags: 

You might like:

The Wall Street Journal: Whitefish halts Puerto Rico power repairs over $83 million in unpaid bills The Wall Street Journal: Whitefish halts Puerto Rico power repairs over $83 million in unpaid bills
NewsWatch: This chart on research productivity is bad news for the stock market NewsWatch: This chart on research productivity is bad news for the stock market
How to talk to your family about bitcoin at Thanksgiving dinner How to talk to your family about bitcoin at Thanksgiving dinner
Market Extra: Bitcoin breaks $8,000 milestone and keeps on rising Market Extra: Bitcoin breaks $8,000 milestone and keeps on rising
The Wall Street Journal: Justice Department sues AT&T, Time Warner over potential merger The Wall Street Journal: Justice Department sues AT&T, Time Warner over potential merger
The Wall Street Journal: Shares of Outback Steakhouse parent surge after Jana discloses large stake The Wall Street Journal: Shares of Outback Steakhouse parent surge after Jana discloses large stake
One major way U.S. credit-card debt is getting worse One major way U.S. credit-card debt is getting worse
Amazon’s sketchy health products could hurt its big pharmacy ambitions Amazon’s sketchy health products could hurt its big pharmacy ambitions

Leave a Reply

Submit Comment
© 2017 Stock Investors News. All rights reserved. XHTML / CSS Valid.